+- Apnea Board Forum - CPAP | Sleep Apnea (https://www.apneaboard.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Public Area (https://www.apneaboard.com/forums/Forum-Public-Area)
+--- Forum: Main Apnea Board Forum (https://www.apneaboard.com/forums/Forum-Main-Apnea-Board-Forum)
+--- Thread: [Equipment] HDM Z1 Auto? (/Thread-Equipment-HDM-Z1-Auto)
HDM Z1 Auto? - FrogLick - 12-23-2016
I'm always looking for a smaller travel CPAP and the HDM Z1 is appealing but reviews show a lot of disappointment. Specifically the noise level and difficulty upon exhalation (and sometimes inhalation too). Since the original reviews were posted they now have a newer Z1 Auto model. Are there any users who know if the noise issue has been addressed and if the pressure relief programming has been modified for greater comfory?
RE: HDM Z1 Auto? - OMyMyOHellYes - 12-24-2016
The Z1 Auto has been out a looooooooooog time. It is not a new development. And all the crap that was put on the Z1 applies equally to the Z1 Auto.
Now, along the way HDM did update the firmware for a different breathing Al Gore rhythm (for the life of me, I can't see that doofus dancing, but ...). I think they also finally gave up saying it was so super quiet and did start marketing a semi-disposable muffler that you would add between the machine and the hose so folks could sleep over all that quietness that sounded like a diesel big rig turbo spooling up with every breath.
In my opinion, by the time all that is said and done, you are not really saving much travel space. You have a collection of smaller components that make up a bigger assembly that really offers no beneft over a small all in one travel unit.
So I ditched mine (Z1) and got an S-8 Autoset II (still available new in box!) Older design, built like a tank, works extrasupurbular. But reasonably compact and all in one unit - not even a separate power supply(and I have been told by a reputable DME/tech that has disassembled both that comparing the Z1 to one of the Traditional machines is like comparing working on a Yugo vs a BMW). Also in the same mold as the S-8 would be the DeVillbiss Intellipap Auto.
Some folks will tell you size doesn't matter. But I am told that is a myth....
OMMOHY
RE: HDM Z1 Auto? - trish6hundred - 12-24-2016
Hi FrogLick,
WELCOME! to the forum.!
Hang in there for more responses to your post and good luck to you with your CPAP therapy.
RE: HDM Z1 Auto? - sonicboom - 12-25-2016
I strongly considered a small travel option like the Z1 but after researching it here and elsewhere I decided that simply travelling with my home unit (A10), given it is not that large and is not that heavy and fits in a nice buffered travel case, was the right choice for me. Since you are using your home unit when doing this no compromises or changes are necessary to your therapy.
RE: HDM Z1 Auto? - FrogLick - 12-25-2016
My current travel machine is an S-8, I like that it doesn't require a separate power brick, and it works well. Considering that the Z1 requires a power brick the size & weight isn't better and the other "issues" would seem to eliminate it as a replacement contender.
RE: HDM Z1 Auto? - bill-e - 12-26-2016
I've been using the Z1 Family since they came out and I wouldn't travel with anything else. I travel 35-45 weeks a year by plane so the weight and size are a big deal to me.
To answer your specific question. The Z1 Auto at the APAP-2 setting is a comfortable to breath and exhale as my PR System 1.
Noise, yes they are noisy because of the small high speed blower. I used mine for years and slept just fine. Then HDM came out with the Q-Tube and that in my opinion makes the machine quiet enough for most people and sleeping partners.